By: Leanna Renee Hieber
NOTE – Special thanks to NetGalley and Castle Bridge Media for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book was…..disappointing.
I’ve read a lot of what Leanna Renee Hieber has to offer and have loved her previous work. I found her writing to be atmospheric, emotional, ethereal and haunting. She seems to be born to write gothic horror stories.
But this book wasn’t like that. It felt flat, rushed, preachy and weak.
What I enjoyed:
- The initial ghostly story line was lovely. A rich heritage with a good background to it.
- The settings. The Glacier and Denny mansions had character all their own and breathed along with the people inhabiting them. Glacier Mansion especially seemed to be waiting and expectant, wanting to be released from whatever hold the Denny Mansion had on it. The surrounding village being affected with winding streets held its own within the confines of the surrounding trees and rocks. It was very atmospheric and set the tone well for a good ghost story.
- The pacing of the story was at a good clip. No lagging or waiting around much for a conclusion.
What I didn’t enjoy:
- Flat characters and very little emotional depth. I’m not used to that from this author. I’m used to having an emotional attachment to the folks in Hieber’s books and I didn’t get any of that. Honestly, I couldn’t have cared less about Lillian or Camile or Nathaniel or William. Bethany and Carmen seemed to be just there but they also had no real substance.
- Character relationships. I sorta could buy the instant relationship between Lillian and Nathaniel because of William and Camille although the whole idea of the latter reliving their lives through the former was a bit unbelievable. But anything else felt contrived and forced.
- I’m not a fan of being preached at. I certainly don’t mind when a book includes LGBTQ+ characters when it feels natural and it makes sense to the story. This did not. The characters representing were preachy to the point of distraction. It felt more like the author was making a statement that felt forced instead of part of the story. Not a fan at all.
All in all, this was a good effort but I expected much more from this author based on past work. This didn’t cut it for me and I was left disappointed.
My rating: :star: :star:




